top of page

TRIAL OF SUMMONS-CASES BY MAGISTRATES

CHAPTER XXI

274. Substance of accusation to be stated

275. Conviction on plea of guilty

276. Conviction on plea of guilty in absence of accused in petty cases

277. Procedure when not convicted

278. Acquittal or conviction

279. Non-appearance or death of complainant

280. Withdrawal of complaint

281. Power to stop proceedings in certain cases

282. Power of Court to convert summons-cases into warrant-cases

Based on Chapter XXI (Trial of Summons-Cases by Magistrates) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), here are 30 preliminary-style questions designed to test memory, understanding, and analytical skills.

Q1. Under Section 274, when an accused appears in a summons-case, what is the first mandatory step for the Magistrate?
A) To frame a formal charge in writing.
B) To state the particulars of the offence and ask the accused if they plead guilty.
C) To immediately record the evidence of the complainant.
D) To demand a list of defense witnesses.

Q2. Is it legally necessary to frame a formal charge in a summons-case under Section 274?
A) Yes, for all cases punishable with more than 3 months.
B) No, it shall not be necessary to frame a formal charge.
C) Yes, if the Public Prosecutor requests it.
D) Only if the accused is a proclaimed offender.

Q3. (New BNSS Update) According to the proviso to Section 274, what can a Magistrate do if they consider the accusation against the accused to be groundless?
A) Commit the case to the Court of Session.
B) Release the accused, which shall have the effect of a discharge.
C) Acquit the accused immediately.
D) Order the complainant to be imprisoned.

Q4. Under Section 275, if an accused pleads guilty, how must the Magistrate record the plea?
A) In a summary of the Magistrate's own words.
B) As nearly as possible in the words used by the accused.
C) Only in the presence of two gazetted officers.
D) Via a video recording only.

Q5. What is the scope of the Magistrate's discretion when an accused pleads guilty under Section 275?
A) The Magistrate must acquit the accused.
B) The Magistrate is bound to convict the accused.
C) The Magistrate shall record the plea and may, in his discretion, convict the accused.
D) The Magistrate must refer the case to the High Court for sentencing.

Q6. Section 276 deals with conviction on a plea of guilty in the absence of the accused in which type of cases?
A) Non-cognizable cases.
B) Petty cases where a summons was issued under Section 229.
C) Any case where the fine is less than ₹10,000.
D) Only cases involving motor vehicle accidents.

Q7. Under Section 276, how can an accused transmit their plea of guilty and the fine amount to the Magistrate?
A) Only through a legal advocate.
B) By post or by messenger.
C) Via a telephone call to the Court clerk.
D) Only by appearing through audio-video conferencing.

Q8. If the Magistrate does not convict the accused on a plea of guilty, which section governs the subsequent procedure for taking evidence?
A) Section 274.
B) Section 277.
C) Section 280.
D) Section 282.

Q9. Under Section 277(1), the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the _____ and take all such evidence as may be produced.
A) Accused.
B) Prosecution.
C) Victim's family.
D) Investigating Officer.

Q10. According to Section 277(2), can a Magistrate issue a summons to a witness to produce a document?
A) No, only the police can do this.
B) Yes, on the application of the prosecution or the accused.
C) Only if the witness resides outside the district.
D) Only in warrant-cases.

Q11. Under Section 278(1), if the Magistrate finds the accused not guilty after taking evidence, they shall record an order of:
A) Discharge.
B) Release.
C) Acquittal.
D) Dismissal.

Q12. According to Section 278(3), can a Magistrate convict an accused of an offence not mentioned in the complaint or summons?
A) No, it is strictly prohibited.
B) Yes, if the facts admitted or proved show they committed it and no prejudice is caused.
C) Only if the complainant agrees in writing.
D) Only if the offence is non-bailable.

Q13. (New BNSS Update) Under Section 279(1), if the complainant is absent on the day of hearing, the Magistrate must give them how much time to be present before taking further action?
A) Seven days.
B) Fourteen days.
C) Thirty days.
D) Sixty days.

Q14. What is the effect of the Magistrate's decision to dispense with the accused's appearance when the complainant is absent under Section 279?
A) The accused is discharged.
B) The accused is acquitted.
C) The case is transferred to the police.
D) The complainant is fined.

Q15. Under the proviso to Section 279(1), a Magistrate may proceed with the case despite the complainant's absence if:
A) The complainant is a public servant and their personal attendance is not required.
B) The complainant has died and the Magistrate thinks it proper to continue.
C) Both A and B.
D) Neither A nor B.

Q16. Section 280 allows for the withdrawal of a complaint at what stage?
A) At any time before a final order is passed.
B) Only before the evidence begins.
C) Only with the consent of the accused.
D) Only in the Court of Session.

Q17. What is the legal effect of a withdrawal of a complaint under Section 280?
A) Discharge of the accused.
B) Stay of proceedings.
C) Acquittal of the accused.
D) Dismissal of the case with a fine on the complainant.

Q18. Section 281 deals with the power to stop proceedings in certain cases. To which category of cases does this section apply?
A) Cases instituted on a private complaint.
B) Any summons-case instituted otherwise than upon complaint (e.g., police report).
C) Only compoundable offences.
D) Only offences punishable with fine only.

Q19. Under Section 281, if the Magistrate stops proceedings after the evidence of the principal witnesses has been recorded, they shall pronounce a judgment of:
A) Discharge.
B) Acquittal.
C) Conviction.
D) Release.

Q20. If a Magistrate stops proceedings under Section 281 before the evidence of principal witnesses is recorded, the release of the accused has the effect of:
A) Acquittal.
B) Conviction.
C) Discharge.
D) Forfeiture.

Q21. Under Section 282, what is the maximum punishment of an offence that allows a Magistrate to convert a summons-case into a warrant-case?
A) Imprisonment exceeding three months.
B) Imprisonment exceeding six months.
C) Imprisonment exceeding one year.
D) Any offence regardless of punishment.

Q22. When converting a summons-case into a warrant-case under Section 282, what criteria must the Magistrate satisfy?
A) It must be in the interest of justice.
B) The complainant must give consent.
C) The accused must request it in writing.
D) The High Court must issue a notification.

Q23. If a case is converted under Section 282, the Magistrate must:
A) Recall any examined witnesses to be re-heard.
B) Pass a judgment immediately.
C) Dismiss the existing evidence and start fresh.
D) Transfer the case to a different Magistrate.

Q24. Logic Question: Why does Section 274 distinguish between \"release\" (discharge) and \"acquittal\" in a summons trial?
A) Because \"release\" happens before a trial begins and \"acquittal\" happens after evidence.
B) To protect the Magistrate from liability.
C) Because summons trials never end in acquittal.
D) There is no legal distinction between the two in BNSS.

Q25. Problem Question: 'A' is accused of a summons-case offence. At the first hearing, the Magistrate finds the evidence in the police report totally lacks substance. Can 'A' be discharged?
A) No, there is no provision for discharge in summons-cases.
B) Yes, under Section 274, the Magistrate can release him with the effect of discharge.
C) Only if 'A' pays a bond for good behavior.
D) No, the trial must be completed once cognizance is taken.

Q26. Scenario: In a police-instituted summons trial, the Investigating Officer fails to appear as a witness for 10 months. Can the Magistrate stop the trial?
A) No, only the Sessions Judge can stop a police case.
B) Yes, under Section 281, the Magistrate can stop proceedings in cases not based on a private complaint.
C) Only if the accused pleads guilty.
D) Only if the High Court directs it.

Q27. Problem: 'B' files a complaint for simple hurt. On the day of the trial, 'B' dies. Can the Magistrate continue the trial?
A) No, the case must be dismissed immediately.
B) Yes, under the proviso to Section 279, if the Magistrate thinks it proper, they can proceed.
C) Only if 'B's lawyer is present.
D) Only if the offence is cognizable.

Q28. Under Section 273, which also applies to summons-cases via Section 273(8), what is the maximum compensation a Magistrate can award for a groundless accusation?
A) ₹5,000.
B) ₹10,000.
C) Not exceeding the amount of fine the Magistrate is empowered to impose.
D) The amount of the victim's medical bills.

Q29. True or False: In a summons-case trial, the Magistrate is legally required to follow the procedure of a warrant-case if the accused is a woman.
A) True.
B) False.

Q30. Analytical Question: Based on Section 278(2), if a Magistrate finds the accused guilty but believes they should be released on probation, which section must they proceed under?
A) Section 274.
B) Section 364 or Section 401.
C) Section 232.
D) Section 282.

Answer Key and Citations
1. B [36, S. 274]
2. B [36, S. 274]
3. B [36, S. 274 Proviso]
4. B [36, S. 275]
5. C [36, S. 275]
6. B [36, S. 276]
7. B [36, S. 276]
8. B [36, S. 277]
9. B [36, S. 277(1)]
10. B [36, S. 277(2)]
11. C [36, S. 278(1)]
12. B [36, S. 278(3)]
13. C [36, S. 279(1)]
14. B [36, S. 279(1)]
15. C [36, S. 279(1) Proviso]
16. A [36, S. 280]
17. C [36, S. 280]
18. B [36, S. 281]
19. B [36, S. 281]
20. C [36, S. 281]
21. B [36, S. 282]
22. A [36, S. 282]
23. A [36, S. 282]
24. A [Legal Logic based on S. 274 vs S. 278]
25. B [36, S. 274 Proviso]
26. B [36, S. 281]
27. B [36, S. 279(1) Proviso]
28. C [35, S. 273(2) & (8)]
29. B [S. 274 - Summons procedure is standard unless converted under S. 282]
30. B [36, S. 278(2)]

Based on Chapter XXI (Trial of Summons-Cases by Magistrates) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), here are 10 statement-based questions designed to test your knowledge of the procedural updates and core sections.

Q1. Consider the following statements regarding Section 274:
Statement I: When an accused appears in a summons-case, the Magistrate is legally required to frame a formal charge in writing.
Statement II: If the Magistrate considers the accusation to be groundless, he shall, after recording reasons, release the accused, and such release shall have the effect of discharge.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q2. Regarding the conviction on a plea of guilty under Section 275:
Statement I: If the accused pleads guilty, the Magistrate is bound by law to convict him immediately.
Statement II: The Magistrate must record the plea as nearly as possible in the words used by the accused.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q3. Evaluate the following statements regarding Section 276 (Petty cases):
Statement I: An accused can plead guilty and transmit the specified fine via post or messenger without appearing before the Magistrate.
Statement II: For the purposes of this special summons, the specified fine cannot exceed five thousand rupees.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q4. Consider these statements regarding the procedure when an accused is not convicted on a plea of guilty (Section 277):
Statement I: The Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all evidence produced in its support.
Statement II: The Magistrate may, on the application of the prosecution or the accused, issue a summons to any witness to produce any document or thing.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q5. Regarding the final order of the Magistrate under Section 278:
Statement I: If the Magistrate finds the accused not guilty after taking evidence, he shall record an order of acquittal.
Statement II: A Magistrate may convict the accused of any offence triable under Chapter XXI which he appears to have committed from the facts admitted or proved, regardless of the nature of the complaint.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q6. Consider the provisions for non-appearance or death of the complainant under Section 279:
Statement I: If the complainant fails to appear on the day of hearing, the Magistrate shall immediately record an order of acquittal.
Statement II: The Magistrate must give the complainant thirty days' time to be present before acquitting the accused.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q7. Evaluate these statements regarding the withdrawal of a complaint under Section 280:
Statement I: A complainant may, with the consent of the Magistrate, withdraw his complaint at any time before a final order is passed.
Statement II: The withdrawal of a complaint under this section results in the discharge of the accused.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q8. Regarding the power to stop proceedings in certain cases under Section 281:
Statement I: This power applies only to summons-cases instituted upon a private complaint.
Statement II: If the Magistrate stops proceedings after the evidence of the principal witnesses has been recorded, he shall pronounce a judgment of acquittal.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q9. Regarding the conclusion of a summons trial under Section 278:
Statement I: If the Magistrate finds the accused guilty, he must hear the accused on the question of sentence before passing it, unless proceeding under Section 364 or 401.
Statement II: A conviction under this chapter is invalid if the offence proved was not mentioned in the original summons.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Q10. Evaluate the following statements regarding Section 273 (Compensation for groundless accusations):
Statement I: The provisions regarding compensation for groundless accusations apply only to warrant-cases.
Statement II: A Magistrate can order a complainant to pay compensation to the accused not exceeding the amount of fine the Magistrate is empowered to impose.
A) Only Statement I is correct
B) Only Statement II is correct
C) Both Statement I and II are correct
D) Neither Statement I nor II is correct

Answer Key and Citations
Q1. B — Statement I is incorrect because it is not necessary to frame a formal charge in summons-cases. Statement II is correct as per the new proviso to Section 274.
Q2. B — Statement I is incorrect as conviction is at the Magistrate's discretion ("may"). Statement II is correct as per Section 275.
Q3. C — Both statements are correct under Section 276 and the definition of petty offences/Form 31.
Q4. C — Both statements are correct under Section 277(1) and (2).
Q5. C — Both statements are correct as per Section 278(1) and (3).
Q6. B — Statement I is incorrect because the Magistrate must first give thirty days' time. Statement II is correct under Section 279(1).
Q7. A — Statement II is incorrect; withdrawal under Section 280 has the effect of an acquittal, not discharge.
Q8. B — Statement I is incorrect as Section 281 applies to cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint. Statement II is correct under Section 281.
Q9. A — Statement I is correct under Section 278(2). Statement II is incorrect because Section 278(3) allows conviction for any triable offence shown by facts, regardless of the summons.
Q10. B — Statement I is incorrect because Section 273(8) explicitly applies these provisions to summons-cases. Statement II is correct as per Section 273(2).

READY RECKONER

Summons Trial Summary (BNSS, 2023 – Chapter XXI, Sections 274–282)

This "Summons Trial Summary" is your quick ready reckoner for Chapter XXI (Sections 274–282) of the BNSS, 2023. This chapter outlines the streamlined procedure for less serious offences known as summons-cases.

1. The Starting Line: No Formal Charge (Section 274)
• The Procedure:
When the accused appears, the Magistrate states the particulars of the offence and asks for a plea (guilty or not guilty).
The Shortcut: Unlike warrant-cases, it is not necessary to frame a formal charge in writing.
The "Groundless" Exit: A new BNSS update allows the Magistrate to release the accused (which has the effect of a discharge) if they consider the accusation to be groundless.

2. Pleading Guilty (Sections 275–276)
Recording the Plea: The Magistrate must record the plea as nearly as possible in the accused's own words and may then convict them at their discretion.
Petty Offences (S. 276): If a special summons was issued under Section 229, the accused can plead guilty and pay the fine via post or messenger without attending Court.

3. The Evidence Phase (Section 277)
• Hearing the Prosecution:
If the accused does not plead guilty, the Magistrate hears the prosecution and takes all produced evidence.
Witness Summons: The Magistrate can issue summons to witnesses for attendance or the production of documents.

4. The Verdict: Acquittal or Conviction (Section 278)
Acquittal: If the Magistrate finds the accused not guilty after taking evidence, they record an order of acquittal.
Conviction: If found guilty, the Magistrate must hear the accused on the question of sentence before passing it, unless they are dealing with probation.
Flexibility: The Magistrate can convict the accused of any offence triable under this chapter if the proved facts support it, even if it wasn't the offence in the original complaint/summons.

5. Dealing with the Complainant (Sections 279–280)
Absence/Death (S. 279): If the complainant is absent, the Magistrate must give them thirty days' time to appear before taking action. If they still fail to show, the accused is acquitted.
Exceptions: The Magistrate can proceed if the complainant is a public servant, if their attendance isn't necessary, or if the complainant died but the trial should continue.
Withdrawal (S. 280): A complainant can withdraw the complaint at any time before the final order with the Magistrate's consent, resulting in an acquittal.

6. Administrative Powers (Sections 281–282)
Stopping Proceedings (S. 281): In summons-cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint (e.g., police report), the Magistrate can stop proceedings at any stage.
– If stopped after principal witnesses are heard: Acquittal.
– If stopped before: Release (effect of discharge).

Conversion (S. 282): For offences punishable with more than six months of imprisonment, the Magistrate can convert the trial into a warrant-case "in the interests of justice" and re-hear the case.

Quick Revision Tip: "The 30-Day Rule"
In a private complaint summons-case, the Magistrate must give an absent complainant 30 days to appear before they can acquit the accused.

bottom of page